Originally Posted by Premier
the whole "with who?" argument is just as flawed as "anybody but schaub". at some point youre going to have to take a risk and gamble on an unproven commodity. the obvious choices arent going to ever be available. once you really accept that schaub isnt the guy, you have to do something. if you keep asking "with who?" then we we'll keep doing the same thing over and over and schaub will never get replaced. then after 3 more years are flushed down the toilet and 3-4 more mid-round qbs prove to be studs, it will be too late..
You're assuming we can't win a Super Bowl with Matt Schaub.
Again, never been a Schaub fan. I don't like him, never did. But I'd be lying if I said he hasn't played at a high level over the last 6 years. A level high enough to win a Super Bowl.
I know there are times when you see the goofy bastard out there, you shake your head, sometimes drop your head..... face palm.... I mean even the Forest Gump striding Peyton Manning will pick up 5 yards or 7 yards if he needs it to move the chains. Our guy will trip & fumble over his own two feet.
Speaking of Peyton Manning, if I could chose a QB to lead my team, it'd be 18 hands down. He's smarter than everyone else on the field, he reads defenses quick, he manipulates DBs, he understands the game, he's a field general, he's got a laser rocket arm...
But he's only won 1 Super Bowl. So what do I know?
I didn't think Tom Brady was shiz as a QB when he won 3 of them. When I finally thought he belonged in the "Best QB" conversation, he hasn't been able to get it done.
Roethlisberger...... who'd have thunk he would already have won 2