Re: Knowing what we know now, which QB do you go with?
Of the five you listed, I go:
1.) Russell Wilson
2.) Andrew Luck
3.) Joe Flacco
4.) Colin Kaepernick
5.) RG III
QBs I would take right now over Schaub, in no particular order:
Manning, Brees, Rodgers, Brady
Cutler (esp. in this offense)
There are another half dozen that I consider to be so similar to Schaub in terms of effectiveness that there's no sense ranking them.
Guys I think I'd rather have in another year, in no particular order:
All of the above except maaaayyybe Peyton.
maybe Josh Freeman
maybe Ryan Tannehill
Sam Bradford, Andy Dalton, and Nick Foles could possibly develop into a Schaub-type player. At any rate, it's not hard to look around at half the NFL or more and be more excited about their QB than our own.
A real MVP contributes in all phases of the game.