Re: Where does Matt rank with QBs in playoffs
I don't think you can argue that Manning was clutch yesterday. He scored a net 14 points for his team (21 - 7 on the pick 6). He had 4 TOs as well.
Flacco was the better QB yesterday. People aren't going to give him credit until he wins a SB.
Rodgers also wasn't elite yesterday. He didn't play a bad game, but his team got beaten by a QB with only 6 or so starts to his name.
I think this elite/clutch debate is gonna get us nowhere. Ultimately the QB is only a component of the overall team winning. Manning did enough for his team to win, but didn't because his defense was terrible. Ditto for GB.
Schaub needs to play well to win, but his running game and defense are also huge pieces to us winning.