Originally Posted by patsfan13
Well if you look at the record you can make the argument that he is already the GOAT, Tied for most playoff wins with Montana, Montana has 1 more loss than Brady, 1 more SB appearance one more SB loss than Montana. 2nd highest winning % for playoff wins (Bradshaw highest) with QB's > 10 playoff starts.
As Far as the regular season it isn't close, Brady is 1 of 3 QB to win more than 70% of their NFL regular season starts, Montana and Staubach are the other 2, Brady leads with a .777, Staubach is at .745 (although he only has 85 ref season wins whereas Brady and Montana are over 125 wins), Montana has a .713 winning %. A Rogers is only at a .665 winning % and Manning at a .688.
Winning is a team accomplishment. You can't decide who the greatest QB of all time is based on wins or win percentage. According to what you've suggested, Marino & Moon aren't even in the conversation & they should be along with Cunningham, and a bunch of other QBs that were on teams that didn't have the success of Belichick.
The most winningest QB of all time? I'll give you that, but GOAT.... like I said, he's not even GORN.