Originally Posted by GP
On punts, why not just NOT have a return guy back there? Starting at the 1 is as bad as us starting at the 10, and there'd be no chance at Holliday blowing the fair catch.
On kickoffs, put some no-name doof back there, like Keo, and just tell him to down it if it's into the EZ or hold on and do his best if it's in the field of play.
Seriously, wouldn't this be a better way of handling this?.
No it wouldn't.
Why would you intentionally limit yourself?
I don't care who is back there for returns, but you aren't going to put guys back there just to catch the ball.
Also starting on the one is not the same as starting on the 10. Not even close.