Originally Posted by Double Barrel
Both Mannings are badass QBs and I consider both to be elite and destined for the HoF.
If I had to choose just one, though, knowing what I know, I'd pick Eli. Dude is clutch, and with two rings and two SB MVPs, he's not a fluke.
I would go with Peyton. You always have that chance to win with Peyton behind center.