Originally Posted by TexCanada
I just don't think there are that many people who excel at both. They could learn how, but its unlikely that they would be as good as someone who specializes in just one of the two skills.
I would like to hear why one player can't be good at both. Danny White was a very good QB (top all time QB rating when he retired) and a very good punter - that was the most vicious potential for fake punts ever. Those are two much more divergent skill sets.
Thanks for the link. I am still not persuaded.