Originally Posted by The Pencil Neck
Here's what you said earlier...
From that and the fact that everyone who has won a Super Bowl and is still playing is in your Elite class led me to believe that you had SB has one of your main criteria.
Eli's and Roethlisberger's stats are not as impressive as Schaub's.
3 of the last 4 years, the Texans have been in playoff contention late into December. Last year, we should have been except for an epically bad defense. Schaub has consistently put up stats.
You don't like him, fine. But you can't say he's not a good QB.
Again, where did I say winning a Super Bowl automatically makes you a better QB? You still haven't shown me...try again...
Eli and Ben have won games on their own. They have show the entire NFL their clutchness before. They've shown it to YOU.
Schaub is a good QB. He's good at game managing. But sadly, he won't take us where we want to go. His intangibles are severely lacking.
Had Schaub of been the type of QB Ben and Eli are, then we would of gotten into the playoffs those years. But he's not and we didn't.