Originally Posted by JCTexan
I would do #2 & #3. In both you would get clear #1 WR's in Marshall & Smith and would also get a pretty good RB in Thomas. The fact that I like Marshall better makes #2 the clear winner here.
Edit: just realized #4 had DMC in it.. That would change my opinion quite a bit.
Thanks! I'm getting the message that I have given too much rep in the last 24 hours but as soon as I can, I will rep you. I appreciate the advice. That is the way I am leaning.
So are you with Dutch that you think option 1 (me getting Bowe) is a bad deal?
Also, what do you mean in your last sentence? Do you mean that you would do the deal even though it includes McFadden or would not?