It has been a good debate that I have read.. First off I like DD.. I like that he runs hard and seems to fall forward when he gets tackled.. now for people to say elite.. no.. and I am not going to say Hollings is going to be elite either. Both backs bring something unique to the table
To play Devil's advocate here and add to the debate....
Is DD that good or is it that he is the best we have seen in a Texan's uniform so our expectations of him unrealistic?
kinda like what Billy Miller was to us in our 1st season.. (BTW I like Billy too)
I mention this,because DD ,eventhough winning the rookie of the year, was way behind in the probowl race (it is narrowed given williams retired and portis is in the NFC now)