Thread: Trade advice
View Single Post
Old 11-04-2010   #123
Posts: n/a
Default Re: Trade advice

Originally Posted by gtexan02 View Post
Hes offering:
Carson Palmer
Jamal Charles
Donald Driver

Hes wanting:
Eli Manning
Ray Rice
Mike Wallace

Manning and Palmer have been statisticlaly pretty equivelent, although palmer has been slightly better

Rice has been a big disappointment, and Charles has been better, however he has not scored very often

Wallace has performed better than Driver, but he doesn't start most weeks for me
Who are your WRs?

Also even though he is having a down year, his upside is still there and he is the main goal line back even with McGahee so at first glance, you are giving up too much. If you want Palmer, then I guess make the trade but I might keep Eli if I were you. Seems to me the only thing you are getting in this deal is Charles and with the touchdowns or lack thereof for Charles, it doesn't seem like you are really getting better unless you really like Palmer.
  Reply With Quote