Quote:
Originally Posted by Ckw5814
Alright need an answer quick.
Welker, Hightower, and Maclin for Mendenhall, Crabtree, and Spiller. Yes or no?
|
I'd do it. Crabtree will only be as good as his QB...which unfortunately for him is Smith. Unless Smith miraculously turns it around this week, I see Crabtree having low numbers again. Unless Carr comes in and somehow starts playing like Peyton Manning
.
Welker is a beast, Hightower is decent I suppose... you have Arian Foster who will hopefully be able to carry your team, and Maclin is also an uncertainty with Kolb having a concussion and Philly having to rely on Vick. Pretty much the trade is worth it only because you'll be getting Welker
.
*EDIT*
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ckw5814
Or I have the offer of Boldin and Benson for Mendenhall and Crabtree.
|
That trade is a lot better IMO. Low risk, and you are getting an experienced WR with an above average QB (Flacco) instead of a 2nd year WR with a crap QB(Smith). Plus I think Benson will end up having a better season than Mendenhall.