Originally Posted by TheOgre
...I think we can find a guy equally as effective, if not moreso, PLUS find a guy that can contribute in other ways as well.
That would be great, but do the Texans have a guy like that on their roster?
These are the guys competing for the return gig. They aren't likely to contribute significantly in any way except as a returner. It would be nice to have a Randle-El or a Brian Westbrook who could be multi-dimensional. Domanick Davis was drafted to be just that, but he's too valuable to use like that now.
The multi-dimensional argument is a red herring because the Texans don't have that guy on their roster. The return job should go to the best returner, whomever that is. He'll touch the ball 6-7 times a game and is more important than the bottom guy on the depth chart at WR or CB.