Garcia or Delhomme
 

Mclain is reporting via twitter that garcia and delhomme are working out for the team tomorrow. I don't know about you but delhomme looked awful at the end of his career.

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

Din't see my answer.

None of the above.

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

Delhomme, but let's hope Yates does well, stays healthy, and he never gets on the field.

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

Garcia.

He has a never-give-up spirit that I think this team needs right now.

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

I like Jake Delhomme he has been to the superbowl as a starter and played well but lost NE 32 CAR 29.

(16-of-33 for 323 yards, 3 passing touchdowns, no interceptions, and a 113.6 passer rating), as well as setting a record for longest offensive play from scrimmage in Super Bowl history (an 85-yard pass to Muhsin Muhammad), the Panthers fell on a last-minute field goal by Adam Vinatieri.

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

I'm good with it coming down to these two guys. I don't see how Delhomme has much of anything left to offer...his ending in Cleveland was pretty bad.

Garcia is mobile, that ALONE makes him a better choice. Barely.

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

I will just flip a coin! LOL!:thinking:

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

Garcia. Delhomme is/was godawful.

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

Delhome last 2 yrs were pretty bad is that a reflection of him or the talent around him?

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

Remember when he led the Panthers to the #1 seed in the playoffs and chucked 4 INTs against Arizona?

He sucks.

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

I don't usually say anything out loud when reading off my computer...however, I read the thread title and said "Jake Delhomme? F_ck that."

I think that succinctly answers your question.

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

Garcia would be a better fit. He's played in the WC offense. If he had really mpressed Gary last week then I dobt Delhomme would be coming in for a tryout.

Garcia's best attribute at this stage of his career is his wife.

She's extremely hot.

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

Delhome i know last 2 yrs bad.

play off rec. 5W-3L
he has been to the superbowl threw for over 300yds 3td 0int lost to NE

all the things we were saying about leinart applies to him he will be playing with good def and run game

complete stats
http://www.pro-football-reference.co...D/DelhJa00.htm

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

Haha! Pretty much my sentiments exactly.

The rest of John McClain's tweet mentions that Garcia played for Texans QB coach Greg Knapp at San Francisco. He's played in a system similar to what the Texans run.

I would think the Garcia decision would be a snap.

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

I can find negatives and positives for both Garcia and Delhome so I am ok with it either way.

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

Out of the two I'll take Garcia, even if he is 41 years old. Hell, I'd take Vinny Testaverde or Archie Manning over Jake Delhomme. Even David Ca...okay maybe not.

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

I'm sold on Garcia with the HOT wife being the tie breaker! lol!:tiphat:

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

On that basis let's see what Montana is doing, his shoe commercial says he feels like he can play.

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

Garcia wouldn't be a terrible guy to have around. We might as well get him in here and have him start learning the playbook just in case he is needed later on. Its Yates' job to lose though.

Re: Garcia or Delhomme
 

Please not Delhome. That guy was an interception machine his last couple of years. Garcia is old but better for this offense than Delhome. I can't believe this is what we are down to.