PDA

View Full Version : YTF's Mock Draft v1.0


YoungTexanFan
12-14-2010, 12:35 PM
As a basic premise, I'll state that we don't trade up/down/around and keep our picks. There is absolutely zero need to project that level of stuff. Secondly, I believe we'll stay with the 4-3, regardless of coaching changes. Our team is geared towards the 4-3. I do not believe in the 3-4 either, for that matter, but that is my personal philosophy. Also, this mock is done with the assumption that we sign no one of note in the off-season.

1. CB - Brandon Harris - Miami, FL
Harris is not too far behind the "elite 2" CB's that everyone talks about. Since we are not picking in the top 5, we will miss out on both of those CB's. Harris has played extremely well in his match-ups with "name" receivers. I like his physical build and willingness to support the run better than Jenkins. Harris has smooth feet and plays the ball well.

2. WLB - Travis Lewis - Oklahoma
I think we have the start to a good LB core with Ryans and Cushing, but I feel that a WLB who can spy the QB or close on the flats will allow our DB's to play their man more. On top of that, I think Lewis is a flat out stud and just one of those guys who is always around the ball.

3. C - Jake Kirkpatrick - TCU
Depth on the OL. Myers has played better than expected this year, but that is just average, and unfortunately, that is his ceiling. I'd like to see someone who can offer a bigger impact and hold the position down going forward.

4. DE - Greg Romeus - Pittsburgh
You might recognize the name as he was getting a little attention before the season as a possible first or second round pick. He hasn't had a great year and neither has his team. He's got NFL talent and is someone who should fit nicely into our rotation.

5. RB - Kendall Hunter - Oklahoma State
The new Steve Slaton. We will draft a RB. We have our every day guy in Foster, but having a guy like Hunter who can make a play on the outside and take it home is a nice wrinkle to have. Hunter has been productive when healthy.

6. WR - DeAndre Brown - Southern Mississippi
He's the primary WR for his team, and rightfully so. He gets all of the attention and shifts, and still produces. He has a giant frame, which will be nice to have in the redzone. I think he would be a nice piece to our WR rotation and has the ability to subplant Walters or Jones.

7. K/P - Alex Henry - Nebraska
His leg strength is amazing on long field goals. He gets the ball up quickly and carries it on touch backs. I don't think Rackers has been bad at all, but this would be an upgrade. He also doubles as a punter, which could very much use an upgrade.

beerlover
12-14-2010, 01:02 PM
excellent additions across the board. will add lots of quality depth along with possibly 2-3 starters which should keep Texans just above average.

Harris best corner available, but not bpa

Lewis is very productive, so is Sharpton/Diles

Kirkpatrick is a true replacement for Myers

Romeus is excellent sleeper DE pick, had a bit of down year but talent is there.

Kendall Hunter jump all over him if still here?

DeAndre Brown is a good receiver borderline roster/practice squad, just look at Dickerson.

Alex Henry is starting punter day one, good for FG attempts 48 up

Good to read you again YTF :)

badboy
12-14-2010, 01:56 PM
As a basic premise, I'll state that we don't trade up/down/around and keep our picks. There is absolutely zero need to project that level of stuff. Secondly, I believe we'll stay with the 4-3, regardless of coaching changes. Our team is geared towards the 4-3. I do not believe in the 3-4 either, for that matter, but that is my personal philosophy. Also, this mock is done with the assumption that we sign no one of note in the off-season.

1. CB - Brandon Harris - Miami, FL
Harris is not too far behind the "elite 2" CB's that everyone talks about. Since we are not picking in the top 5, we will miss out on both of those CB's. Harris has played extremely well in his match-ups with "name" receivers. I like his physical build and willingness to support the run better than Jenkins. Harris has smooth feet and plays the ball well.

2. WLB - Travis Lewis - Oklahoma
I think we have the start to a good LB core with Ryans and Cushing, but I feel that a WLB who can spy the QB or close on the flats will allow our DB's to play their man more. On top of that, I think Lewis is a flat out stud and just one of those guys who is always around the ball.

3. C - Jake Kirkpatrick - TCU
Depth on the OL. Myers has played better than expected this year, but that is just average, and unfortunately, that is his ceiling. I'd like to see someone who can offer a bigger impact and hold the position down going forward.

4. DE - Greg Romeus - Pittsburgh
You might recognize the name as he was getting a little attention before the season as a possible first or second round pick. He hasn't had a great year and neither has his team. He's got NFL talent and is someone who should fit nicely into our rotation.

5. RB - Kendall Hunter - Oklahoma State
The new Steve Slaton. We will draft a RB. We have our every day guy in Foster, but having a guy like Hunter who can make a play on the outside and take it home is a nice wrinkle to have. Hunter has been productive when healthy.

6. WR - DeAndre Brown - Southern Mississippi
He's the primary WR for his team, and rightfully so. He gets all of the attention and shifts, and still produces. He has a giant frame, which will be nice to have in the redzone. I think he would be a nice piece to our WR rotation and has the ability to subplant Walters or Jones.

7. K/P - Alex Henry - Nebraska
His leg strength is amazing on long field goals. He gets the ball up quickly and carries it on touch backs. I don't think Rackers has been bad at all, but this would be an upgrade. He also doubles as a punter, which could very much use an upgrade.Good to see your stuff again.

1. I really like Harris @ CB but why do you expect Kubiak to go CB again, altough I hope he does? i am also interested in Nick Fairley but a cover Cb shuts down an entire side.
2. i pass on Lb but he is good
3. like the center but do not see Smithiak moving myers.

YoungTexanFan
12-14-2010, 07:44 PM
excellent additions across the board. will add lots of quality depth along with possibly 2-3 starters which should keep Texans just above average.

Harris best corner available, but not bpa
I don't think we're in a position to draft strictly BPA. BPA will likely be a QB like Mallet or a WR like Jones. We draft BPA out of a selective few positions.

Lewis is very productive, so is Sharpton/Diles
I like Sharpton but really dislike Diles and I've made that clear since we drafted him. Could be my bias against his school though. However, Sharpton/Diles aren't that productive and Lewis would upgrade the front/back 7, depending on which you feel is our biggest need.

Kirkpatrick is a true replacement for Myers
I don't know if he's an instant replacement. Myers seems to have the ability to just stick around. I think Kirkpatrick is at least depth and has the ability to challenge for the starting spot.

Romeus is excellent sleeper DE pick, had a bit of down year but talent is there.
This was my thought process as well

Kendall Hunter jump all over him if still here?
There are a lot of other RBs in the draft, and honestly, they are a dime a dozen. The shelf life on RBs is only a few years in most cases. I think his injuries will drop him. I think he could get onto the field because of the pass happy system run at OKST and his ability to help in pass protection.

DeAndre Brown is a good receiver borderline roster/practice squad, just look at Dickerson.
This was more of a BPA pick than anything else. Injury concerns and lack of speed. Natural redzone target though.

Alex Henry is starting punter day one, good for FG attempts 48 up

Good to read you again YTF :)

Thanks for the feedback.

YoungTexanFan
12-14-2010, 07:47 PM
Good to see your stuff again.

1. I really like Harris @ CB but why do you expect Kubiak to go CB again, altough I hope he does? i am also interested in Nick Fairley but a cover Cb shuts down an entire side.
2. i pass on Lb but he is good
3. like the center but do not see Smithiak moving myers.

I don't think Kubiak gets the say in what we pick. I think the new (hopefully) defensive coordinator gets more of an input. Ideally I'd like to draft a FS, as would everyone I'm sure, but there isn't the talent. While Eric Berry was an elite talent, that is an example of what a true FS can do to change a defense and in turn the W/L record.

Also, I think we really do need another top notch LB. Ryans is coming back of a torn knee, Cushing regressed this year, and Diles isn't starter material.

kiwitexansfan
12-14-2010, 08:48 PM
7. K/P - Alex Henry - Nebraska
His leg strength is amazing on long field goals. He gets the ball up quickly and carries it on touch backs. I don't think Rackers has been bad at all, but this would be an upgrade. He also doubles as a punter, which could very much use an upgrade.

Alex Henery does not kick off for the Huskers. They have a specialist who kicks the living )&*#&@(*$& out of the ball.

Wolf6151
12-15-2010, 03:16 AM
1. Harris, best CB available at that point and a desperate need of the Texans. Excellent pick, he's going to be a really good/great cover corner in the NFL.

2. Lewis, excellent pick as well, big upgrade at WLB. If Kubiak makes the pick though he'll never choose Lewis, instead he'll give Sharpton another 2-3 yrs. to prove if he can handle the job and improve.

3. Kirkpatrick, I don't know much about him but I trust some of these guys opinions enough to know that he'd be a good pick. I agree that Kubiak won't replace Myers right away but it would sure be nice to have some quality backup pushing for a starting role.

4. Romeus, if still available he's an excellent depth pick. I'd sure like another DT instead of a DE though.

5. Hunter, I don't know anything about him and it seems early to pick a practice squad RB.

6. Brown, again don't know anything about him but a tall athletic WR is a good pick at this point.

7. Henry, I doubt the Texans get rid of Rackers but if the guy can punt then he'd be a good upgrade over Turk.

Overall I really like this mock draft but I'd like to see a DT chosen at #4 we'll have enough depth at DE with Williams, Smith, Barwin, Anderson, and Jamison. We need an upgrade at both DT spots.

painekiller
12-15-2010, 12:52 PM
Ryans is coming back of a torn knee,

Not to nitpick, but Ryans is out with a torn Achilles tendon. Still a long rehab and most likely a loss of quickness and speed as a by product of the injury.

BigBull17
12-16-2010, 08:25 AM
I wouldn't doubt a trade up if a guy we likes slides a bit. We are in a position that one or two guys can make us ALOT better.

YoungTexanFan
12-16-2010, 12:06 PM
Not to nitpick, but Ryans is out with a torn Achilles tendon. Still a long rehab and most likely a loss of quickness and speed as a by product of the injury.

Thank you for pointing that out. My point on LBs remains the same. We need another high level LB. We cannot get by another season with Zac Diles as our starter. We need an impact LB.

YoungTexanFan
12-16-2010, 12:11 PM
I wouldn't doubt a trade up if a guy we likes slides a bit. We are in a position that one or two guys can make us ALOT better.

I disagree honestly. We (still) need a FS. We need a WOLB. We need a C. We need a legitimate LT; yes, I am still upset we wasted a pick on Brown, and no we aren't turning this thread into why I am right all these years later and now there is a growing interest in making him a LG. We still need a CB. We still need an impact DL other than Mario.

We need impact at a few positions. We don't need talent across the board like before, but we need a serious upgrade to quite a few positions before we can compete. FS and LT would be the most obvious examples, followed by OLB and another starting CB.

We don't have the depth to give picks away. Honestly, very few clubs ever do. And even when they do, it's only for a short period. Fool's gold way of thinking. Injuries happen. Player regression happens. FA happens. Depth is just a fictional word in the NFL.

Errant Hothy
12-16-2010, 12:16 PM
I would love to see Henery in a Texans uni, I just don't think he lasts till the 7th. If you want him you are going to have to pick him up earlier, but the flipside is that I think he could easily cover two roster spots, K and P.

Texan4Ever
12-16-2010, 12:46 PM
[QUOTE=YoungTexanFan;1608483]As a basic premise, I'll state that we don't trade up/down/around and keep our picks. There is absolutely zero need to project that level of stuff. Secondly, I believe we'll stay with the 4-3, regardless of coaching changes. Our team is geared towards the 4-3. I do not believe in the 3-4 either, for that matter, but that is my personal philosophy. Also, this mock is done with the assumption that we sign no one of note in the off-season.

1. CB - Brandon Harris - Miami, FL

Harris is one of my favorite CB prospects. If you see my thread about the top DBs in the 2011 Draft, I've posted some YouTube videos and from what I've seen, he's going to be an absolute stud if he is coached properly.

He can become a ball-hawk but tends to just deflect passes but regardless he is my #2 best CB after Patrick Peterson and ahead of Prince Amukamara.

2. WLB - Travis Lewis - Oklahoma

Lewis is undersized which allows him to fly across the field and make plays. He would be an excellent addition to our roster and he could start as a rookie.

3. C - Jake Kirkpatrick - TCU

One of the better centers in the draft. He is tough as nails and can hold his ground against bigger players.

4. DE - Greg Romeus - Pittsburgh

Not sure how much he falls but he was having one of the best seasons as a DE in the NCAA. Steal if he falls this low.

5. RB - Kendall Hunter - Oklahoma State

He's not big like other smaller backs but he is fast and is not afraid to go between the guards and tackles. Would love to have him on our team.

6. WR - DeAndre Brown - Southern Mississippi

Don't know too much about him but he fills a need for us.

7. K/P - Alex Henry - Nebraska

I've ehard his name but haven't seen him play. If he can punt and kick that's good for us in case our punter goes down or whatever.

badboy
12-18-2010, 03:01 PM
[QUOTE=YoungTexanFan;1608483]As a basic premise, I'll state that we don't trade up/down/around and keep our picks. There is absolutely zero need to project that level of stuff. Secondly, I believe we'll stay with the 4-3, regardless of coaching changes. Our team is geared towards the 4-3. I do not believe in the 3-4 either, for that matter, but that is my personal philosophy. Also, this mock is done with the assumption that we sign no one of note in the off-season.

1. CB - Brandon Harris - Miami, FL

Harris is one of my favorite CB prospects. If you see my thread about the top DBs in the 2011 Draft, I've posted some YouTube videos and from what I've seen, he's going to be an absolute stud if he is coached properly.

He can become a ball-hawk but tends to just deflect passes but regardless he is my #2 best CB after Patrick Peterson and ahead of Prince Amukamara.

2. WLB - Travis Lewis - Oklahoma

Lewis is undersized which allows him to fly across the field and make plays. He would be an excellent addition to our roster and he could start as a rookie.

3. C - Jake Kirkpatrick - TCU

One of the better centers in the draft. He is tough as nails and can hold his ground against bigger players.

4. DE - Greg Romeus - Pittsburgh

Not sure how much he falls but he was having one of the best seasons as a DE in the NCAA. Steal if he falls this low.

5. RB - Kendall Hunter - Oklahoma State

He's not big like other smaller backs but he is fast and is not afraid to go between the guards and tackles. Would love to have him on our team.

6. WR - DeAndre Brown - Southern Mississippi

Don't know too much about him but he fills a need for us.

7. K/P - Alex Henry - Nebraska

I've ehard his name but haven't seen him play. If he can punt and kick that's good for us in case our punter goes down or whatever.I'm going to refer to your paragraph rather than your selection comments. Unless you meant to say we "won't" rather than we "don't" because we have and not too long ago. My opinion is we should have drafted up to select Thomas out of UT for our free safety and would be much better seeing how out #1 Cb worked out.

As low as we will probably be drafting, it should not take a 2nd to move up enough to get Patrick Peterson. If we could get him and keep our #2, I would gladly give a 3rd and 5th & maybe a 4 instead of 5.

YoungTexanFan
12-18-2010, 03:07 PM
[QUOTE=Texan4Ever;1610180]I'm going to refer to your paragraph rather than your selection comments. Unless you meant to say we "won't" rather than we "don't" because we have and not too long ago. My opinion is we should have drafted up to select Thomas out of UT for our free safety and would be much better seeing how out #1 Cb worked out.

As low as we will probably be drafting, it should not take a 2nd to move up enough to get Patrick Peterson. If we could get him and keep our #2, I would gladly give a 3rd and 5th & maybe a 4 instead of 5.

I was referencing this particular draft. As in: "In this mock draft, the Texans to do not trade any picks." I also touched more on this in the next sentence. The actual draft in April is a very fluid process. A lot of movements, and the Texans have certainly done some moving.

I'm not usually a fan of trading up, and I don't think Earl Thomas was worth giving up picks for, honestly. Eric Berry, I would have listened and thought about that one long and hard.

As good as Peterson is, he isn't worth what it would cost to move into the top 3. Even if we tank our season and lose out, we would have to give up our entire first day and then commit a ton of cap space.

badboy
12-18-2010, 03:11 PM
[QUOTE=badboy;1611699]

I was referencing this particular draft. As in: "In this mock draft, the Texans to do not trade any picks." I also touched more on this in the next sentence. The actual draft in April is a very fluid process. A lot of movements, and the Texans have certainly done some moving.

I'm not usually a fan of trading up, and I don't think Earl Thomas was worth giving up picks for, honestly. Eric Berry, I would have listened and thought about that one long and hard.

As good as Peterson is, he isn't worth what it would cost to move into the top 3. Even if we tank our season and lose out, we would have to give up our entire first day and then commit a ton of cap space.I am thinking PP will not go top 5 but I realize I am pushing it.

Texan4Ever
12-18-2010, 05:07 PM
[QUOTE=Texan4Ever;1610180]I'm going to refer to your paragraph rather than your selection comments. Unless you meant to say we "won't" rather than we "don't" because we have and not too long ago. My opinion is we should have drafted up to select Thomas out of UT for our free safety and would be much better seeing how out #1 Cb worked out.

As low as we will probably be drafting, it should not take a 2nd to move up enough to get Patrick Peterson. If we could get him and keep our #2, I would gladly give a 3rd and 5th & maybe a 4 instead of 5.



The paragraph was written by someone else, but the blue are my comments...just thought I'd point that out. I wish the Texans would move up the draft to grab a guy they know that can help out on defense (or offense). I would much rather give up a few later picks and move up to get sure talent than use our later picks to grab developmental types.

Wolf6151
12-18-2010, 11:17 PM
[QUOTE=YoungTexanFan;1611702]I am thinking PP will not go top 5 but I realize I am pushing it.

I think your right. I think after the combine Peterson will fall and be better suited at FS than CB.

badboy
12-22-2010, 02:24 PM
[QUOTE=badboy;1611704]

I think your right. I think after the combine Peterson will fall and be better suited at FS than CB.In my dream world, we select Peterson with our # 10 and then trade with New England for their higher first round pick (another team's) say our 2nd this year and 1st & 3rd from next year. We then select Nick Fairley. We then trade for N.E.'s later first round pick giving up our 3rd & 4th & 5th this year and our 2nd round next year. We then select Brandon Harris CB late in first.

BigBull17
12-22-2010, 03:19 PM
I disagree honestly. We (still) need a FS. We need a WOLB. We need a C. We need a legitimate LT; yes, I am still upset we wasted a pick on Brown, and no we aren't turning this thread into why I am right all these years later and now there is a growing interest in making him a LG. We still need a CB. We still need an impact DL other than Mario.

We need impact at a few positions. We don't need talent across the board like before, but we need a serious upgrade to quite a few positions before we can compete. FS and LT would be the most obvious examples, followed by OLB and another starting CB.

We don't have the depth to give picks away. Honestly, very few clubs ever do. And even when they do, it's only for a short period. Fool's gold way of thinking. Injuries happen. Player regression happens. FA happens. Depth is just a fictional word in the NFL.

That's honestly what free agents are for. You address a few needs there and then can play the draft and move up to get a guy or down to get more picks. We almost refuse to do that most of the time.

steelbtexan
12-22-2010, 07:02 PM
[QUOTE=Wolf6151;1611919]In my dream world, we select Peterson with our # 10 and then trade with New England for their higher first round pick (another team's) say our 2nd this year and 1st & 3rd from next year. We then select Nick Fairley. We then trade for N.E.'s later first round pick giving up our 3rd & 4th & 5th this year and our 2nd round next year. We then select Brandon Harris CB late in first.

A man can dream. LOL

Teams that can get 2 great players and a starter out of each draft are doing well. This is why I will always trade up to get the chance of selecting two great players at the end of rd.1 or the top of rd.2. Even if that means it wipes out rds 3/4 picks. But solid difference makers can be found for ST's/depth. (See Bentley,Dickerson/Briesel etc....

My philosopy is to add 2 difference makers in the draft and 1 in FA a yr. The FA's dont have to be the highest paid at their position. A guy that would help in FA that wouldn't cost alot but would upgrade the WLB for instance would be Thoams Howard.

If the Texans followed my philosopy they would have a team with 10 young star players and 10 other guys that can really play. Bottom line is. This team is lacking playmakers and it's time that somebody should pay with thier jobs.

Corrosion
12-24-2010, 04:14 PM
2. WLB - Travis Lewis - Oklahoma
I think we have the start to a good LB core with Ryans and Cushing, but I feel that a WLB who can spy the QB or close on the flats will allow our DB's to play their man more. On top of that, I think Lewis is a flat out stud and just one of those guys who is always around the ball.


I really dont think this team can bank on Ryans coming back 100%. There has to be a backup plan there .... Unless Sharpton is your guy in the middle , they have to pick up a MLB at some point be it by draft or FA.

TexansSeminole
12-24-2010, 05:44 PM
What's wrong with BPA in the first round outside of QB? Julio Jones would do wonders for this team. Walter is overrated. He had a good year, but has been lackluster since. JJ is a failure at receiver, he makes occasional plays but still a failure. DA isn't going anywhere growth wise. We need another receiver, so taking Julio Jones wouldn't be a bad thing for us.

I think we have young enough corners, we need a veteran corner or two to add to the roster. I'd target BPA in the first round and then look for a safety, defensive line, and offensive line in rounds 2-4.

Corrosion
12-24-2010, 06:01 PM
What's wrong with BPA in the first round outside of QB? Julio Jones would do wonders for this team. Walter is overrated. He had a good year, but has been lackluster since. JJ is a failure at receiver, he makes occasional plays but still a failure. DA isn't going anywhere growth wise. We need another receiver, so taking Julio Jones wouldn't be a bad thing for us.

I think we have young enough corners, we need a veteran corner or two to add to the roster. I'd target BPA in the first round and then look for a safety, defensive line, and offensive line in rounds 2-4.

I'd be ok with BPA outside of three positions - QB , RB , WR.

This team is "Good Enough" at those postions and downright piss poor at so many others that I'd be looking at FS , CB , DT , OG and C first .... They also need to have a contingency plan in place should Ryans not return to form.

TexansSeminole
12-24-2010, 06:03 PM
I'd be ok with BPA outside of three positions - QB , RB , WR.

This team is "Good Enough" at those postions and downright piss poor at so many others that I'd be looking at FS , CB , DT , OG and C first .... They also need to have a contingency plan in place should Ryans not return to form.

I agree with everything you said except we are "good enough" at receiver. Outside of AJ, we really have nothing. God forbid he goes down and we have to rely on Walter, JJ, and DA.

Corrosion
12-24-2010, 06:26 PM
I agree with everything you said except we are "good enough" at receiver. Outside of AJ, we really have nothing. God forbid he goes down and we have to rely on Walter, JJ, and DA.

They beat a pretty good Raiders defense this year without AJ and lost him for 7 games in 07 .... They can win with what they have at reciever , they cant win with what they have in the defensive secondary.

Could they use another reciever ? Sure. But they are so much worse at multiple positions .... Maybe Dorin Dickerson , Trindon Holliday or Derrick Townsel makes a marked improvement.

Rey
12-24-2010, 08:03 PM
They beat a pretty good Raiders defense this year without AJ and lost him for 7 games in 07 .... They can win with what they have at reciever , they cant win with what they have in the defensive secondary.

Could they use another reciever ? Sure. But they are so much worse at multiple positions .... Maybe Dorin Dickerson , Trindon Holliday or Derrick Townsel makes a marked improvement.

That sounds eerily similar to the line of thinking that got us into this mess....

Kevin Walter should be a very good role player, but we can easily do better with a starting #2 receiver...

Corrosion
12-24-2010, 08:36 PM
That sounds eerily similar to the line of thinking that got us into this mess....

Kevin Walter should be a very good role player, but we can easily do better with a starting #2 receiver...

You have a point there .... but this offense ranks in the top 10 in just about every category. Its the defense thats the main culprit in this teams losing record.

Rey
12-24-2010, 08:50 PM
You have a point there .... but this offense ranks in the top 10 in just about every category. Its the defense thats the main culprit in this teams losing record.

Oh I agree...

I'm just saying that if there is an offensive talent on the board that is rated a 10 and a defensive player that is a 7.5 or 8, I'd take the offensive player. Doesn't hurt to make a good unit even better.

I look at last years draft....Would you rather have had Kareem Jackson or Dez Bryant?

I know we cannot forecast the rest of their careers from one year, but even at the time Dez was widely considered as the better prospect...

I think Dez would have helped to make us a better team....Definitely this year, and most likely in the future...

I just don't want to pass up an extremely talented offensive player in lieu of forcing a defensive pick...

beerlover
12-24-2010, 09:04 PM
Oh I agree...

I'm just saying that if there is an offensive talent on the board that is rated a 10 and a defensive player that is a 7.5 or 8, I'd take the offensive player. Doesn't hurt to make a good unit even better.

I look at last years draft....Would you rather have had Kareem Jackson or Dez Bryant?

I know we cannot forecast the rest of their careers from one year, but even at the time Dez was widely considered as the better prospect...

I think Dez would have helped to make us a better team....Definitely this year, and most likely in the future...

I just don't want to pass up an extremely talented offensive player in lieu of forcing a defensive pick...

bigger question in my mind is how they rated Kareem above Devin McCourty? same position/need yet they felt Jackson graded out higher because of Sabin system/coaching/level of competition but seeing them perform @ next level McCourty looks better in every aspect. hips are looser, can adjust to the ball in midair, better long speed & back peddle just to name a few. about the only thing I can think of that might of swayed their opinion was during the interview process. in this department Kareem must have done an excellent job selling himself.

JB
12-24-2010, 09:08 PM
bigger question in my mind is how they rated Kareem above Devin McCourty? same position/need yet they felt Jackson graded out higher because of Sabin system/coaching/level of competition but seeing them perform @ next level McCourty looks better in every aspect. hips are looser, can adjust to the ball in midair, better long speed & back peddle just to name a few. about the only thing I can think of that might of swayed their opinion was during the interview process. in this department Kareem must have done an excellent job selling himself.

I think a big part of that is coaching at the NFL level.

Corrosion
12-24-2010, 09:27 PM
Oh I agree...

I'm just saying that if there is an offensive talent on the board that is rated a 10 and a defensive player that is a 7.5 or 8, I'd take the offensive player. Doesn't hurt to make a good unit even better.

I look at last years draft....Would you rather have had Kareem Jackson or Dez Bryant?

I know we cannot forecast the rest of their careers from one year, but even at the time Dez was widely considered as the better prospect...

I think Dez would have helped to make us a better team....Definitely this year, and most likely in the future...

I just don't want to pass up an extremely talented offensive player in lieu of forcing a defensive pick...

Of course - prior to the BS Bryant was widely considered the best WR in the draft. His stock only fell because of the off field issues. I'd have taken him long before the Shitpies did ....

And I do agree , if there is an offensive talent rated a 10 and the best defenders on the board are 7.5-8 you take that much better talent ... But if they are much closer together talent wise - which is much more likely mid first round , you fix whats broken.

Corrosion
12-24-2010, 09:28 PM
bigger question in my mind is how they rated Kareem above Devin McCourty? same position/need yet they felt Jackson graded out higher because of Sabin system/coaching/level of competition but seeing them perform @ next level McCourty looks better in every aspect. hips are looser, can adjust to the ball in midair, better long speed & back peddle just to name a few. about the only thing I can think of that might of swayed their opinion was during the interview process. in this department Kareem must have done an excellent job selling himself.

Yeah , the interview process matters when you need to make a play ... :kubepalm:


Kinda like being a chiorboy or a jackass off the field ....

YoungTexanFan
12-26-2010, 02:56 PM
bigger question in my mind is how they rated Kareem above Devin McCourty? same position/need yet they felt Jackson graded out higher because of Sabin system/coaching/level of competition but seeing them perform @ next level McCourty looks better in every aspect. hips are looser, can adjust to the ball in midair, better long speed & back peddle just to name a few. about the only thing I can think of that might of swayed their opinion was during the interview process. in this department Kareem must have done an excellent job selling himself.

As was pointed out, this is 100% NFL coaching. Everything about Jackson coming out indicated he was a better prospect with less chance to bust. Step back and consider the coaching differences between NE and HOU.