PDA

View Full Version : My Crazy Dream About an Andre Johnson Trade


dickieb
01-09-2008, 11:36 PM
I just had a crazy dream that Miami offered us their 2008 1st and 2nd round draft picks (#1 & #33 overall) for Andre - would you do it? What is the minimum it would take for you to trade Andre, and what would be a realistic trade value be for Andre?

ATX
01-09-2008, 11:42 PM
I just had a crazy dream that Miami offered us their 2008 1st and 2nd round draft picks (#1 & #33 overall) for Andre - would you do it? What is the minimum it would take for you to trade Andre, and what would be a realistic trade value be for Andre?

Never, he's worth atleast 2 first rounders at the min. He's in his prime and a top 5 WR and will only get better. It would take alot to trade for him IMHO. Sounds more like you had a nightmare than a dream.

TEXANS84
01-09-2008, 11:44 PM
Yeah no.
Thought wouldn't even come to mind to trade our best player.

BigBull17
01-09-2008, 11:48 PM
Id say he is the 3rd best WR in the NFL. Hell no I wouldnt trade him. If you take his numbers and stretch it out over the whole season, he would have nbeen close to TO and not as far behind Moss. How would you even begin to replace him? Not possibele. Oh, and BTW, his cap hit would cripple us horribly.

Grid
01-09-2008, 11:51 PM
If they threw in in their 2009 1st rounder, Jason Allen, Matt Roth, and Ronnie Brown... id consider it... but id probably still have alot of reservations about it.

Beer and Metal
01-10-2008, 12:01 AM
Holy carp! you scared the koi outta me!

AnthonyE
01-10-2008, 12:01 AM
What a horrifying question!

I dare not even answer.

(...hell no...)

hookinreds
01-10-2008, 12:11 AM
I just had a crazy dream that Miami offered us their 2008 1st and 2nd round draft picks (#1 & #33 overall) for Andre - would you do it? What is the minimum it would take for you to trade Andre, and what would be a realistic trade value be for Andre?

That's not a dream, it's a nightmare!

Joe Texan
01-10-2008, 12:12 AM
Dude Put down the crack pipe, flush the weed and pour out your Bottle of alcohol, Quit dropping the acid and just go to sleep please

The Pencil Neck
01-10-2008, 12:12 AM
Moderators?

Can we rename this damn thread to show that it's just some horrible nightmare scenario?

This scared the snot right out of my nose.

adam
01-10-2008, 12:27 AM
2 1st round draft picks, Tom Brady, and Randy Moss. Anything less would be a stupid trade in my opinion.

TexanSam
01-10-2008, 12:42 AM
Miami's 1st, 2nd, and 3rd round picks this year. Their 1st and 2nd rounders next year. Jason Taylor and Zach Thomas and their hottest cheerleader

AnthonyE
01-10-2008, 12:49 AM
Miami's 1st, 2nd, and 3rd round picks this year. Their 1st and 2nd rounders next year. Jason Taylor and Zach Thomas and their hottest cheerleader


O_O Bibiana Julian?! *drool* Reluctantly, I'd trade AJ for only her.


Good thing I'm not GM.

Dread-Head
01-10-2008, 01:06 AM
I just had a crazy dream that Miami offered us their 2008 1st and 2nd round draft picks (#1 & #33 overall) for Andre - would you do it? What is the minimum it would take for you to trade Andre, and what would be a realistic trade value be for Andre?



AAAAAAAGH! Dude. Don't even kid around like that! You scared the hellouttame!

CTWade
01-10-2008, 02:25 AM
In my estimation Andre Johnson is just about the equal of any wide receiver in the league, but without the prima donna complex that seems to plague other top tier receivers. A guy can honestly look around the league and say, "Really, nobody is upgrade over Andre." Doesn't seem wise to me give or trade away players like that.

Some of the things Andre did this year.... he just didn't make plays, he made art. He moved me. He made my jaw drop. Just thinking about watching him playing with Matt Schaub in the years to come gives me goose bumps. Even daring to dream of trading Andre away almost seems like blasphemy against the pure essence of football that we all love. I mean things like Schaub-to-Andre are the kind of reasons we watch the game in the first place.

Malloy
01-10-2008, 04:42 AM
Never, he's worth atleast 2 first rounders at the min. He's in his prime and a top 5 WR and will only get better. It would take alot to trade for him IMHO. Sounds more like you had a nightmare than a dream.

But but but... AJ is injury prone!

Well, more injury prone than Dayne :)

Silver Oak
01-10-2008, 08:51 AM
no one is untouchable IMO, in the pursuit of a SB ring, but for AJ, it would have to be a hell of a deal consisting of young, solid players who would fill two of our needs, and then they would have to enhance it with a semi-high draft pick.


texanstalk.com server would probably melt down after the trade however so scratch it.

CloakNNNdagger
01-10-2008, 11:34 AM
Sell crazy somewhere else. We're all stocked up here.

Melvin (As Good As It Gets) :dangit:

HOU-TEX
01-10-2008, 11:47 AM
Sounds like more of a hallucinogen you had rather than a dream. :elle:

nunusguy
01-10-2008, 11:53 AM
I just had a crazy dream that Miami offered us their 2008 1st and 2nd round draft picks (#1 & #33 overall) for Andre - would you do it? What is the minimum it would take for you to trade Andre, and what would be a realistic trade value be for Andre?
Cap considerations aside (which is as silly as suggesting such a trade would actually be there), but of course you pull the trigger on that deal. And hey I'm an AJ fan and he's easily our most valubale offensive player.

Ole Miss Texan
01-10-2008, 12:12 PM
I might do it for their 1st and 2nd this year and 1st next year...but I don't think Miami would be willing to part with that. I'm a big AJ fan but you gotta look at building our team up to a solid contender.

With the #1 overall I try and trade down a few spots with someone wanting Chris Long, Glenn Dorsey, or McFadden. I would take an undervalued trade just picking up a 2nd rounder to move down a few spots which would normally take another 1st rd pick. With apprx the 5th overall I try the exact same thing with someone wanting some other top tiered talent... move down a few more spots (nothing significant) and picking up another 1st day pick or future 1st day + this years 1st.

This isn't always the smart thing to do (take an uneven trade) but in our situation I think it would be a good move. We have drafted very very well the last two years and having multiple 1st day picks this year and in future years would be great with Kubiak and Smith running the show. I don't want to pay top 5 pick money at all. I think a lot of people/ teams would be for this but of course actually finding a trade down partner multiple times is very tough to do...that's why you have to let them have a great deal. Much much much easier said than done.

WesmanTexanfan
01-10-2008, 12:17 PM
nooooooooo

nothing short of the first, second and 3rd overall pick, or maybe the pats or minesota entire O line

BigBull17
01-10-2008, 12:22 PM
Cap considerations aside (which is as silly as suggesting such a trade would actually be there), but of course you pull the trigger on that deal. And hey I'm an AJ fan and he's easily our most valubale offensive player.

So tell me, who do you draft with those picks to replace him? There is minimal improvement considering you lose one of the best in football, for 2 picks that COULD be good. They could also stink. Yeah, pull the trigger on the gun you point at Parcells for even suggesting anything so rediculous. If we got their 1st,2nd, and 3rd for the next 2 years, maybe.

I dont lknow how any body can see a way to improve by losing the BEST PLAYER ON YOUR TEAM! And one of a few guys on our team that could start for anybody in the NFL. Who do we draft to replace him? Dre Davis and Walter are ok, but come on.

Grid
01-10-2008, 12:37 PM
you dont trade a young superstar for the chance of getting another young superstar.. or even the chance of getting two young superstars. A bird in hand is better than two in the bush, so to speak.

ObsiWan
01-10-2008, 12:51 PM
I just had a crazy dream that Miami offered us their 2008 1st and 2nd round draft picks (#1 & #33 overall) for Andre - would you do it? What is the minimum it would take for you to trade Andre, and what would be a realistic trade value be for Andre?

you need to stop smokin' dat sh!t before you go to bed, dude.

I would not trade A.J. for anyone.
Not even for Randy Moss (or Wes Welker) AND Asante Samuels, 2 fer one, plus a second day pick.
...although I'd probably think about it for a minute.
I can't think of any two players that Miami has that I'd want. Their defensive stars are on the downhill slide and they have no one that shows any promise on offense. And no, I'm not sold on Ted Ginn, Jr.

this thread brought to you by another "RealManofGenius"... "Mr. Impossible Trade Suggestion Man"

gtexan02
01-10-2008, 01:05 PM
I dont think theres enough talent difference between top of 1st and middle of 1st. At least, not enough to cover the enormous cost difference. At this point in time, I'd rather spend our money on more good players than 1 great player

ObsiWan
01-10-2008, 01:13 PM
Lest ye forget, was it not just last year (or the year before) that A.J. restructured his contract to allow us to have more cap room and to insure he would remain a Texan. And this is how you repay his loyalty by shipping him away for draft picks, in what I believe is the weakest draft class in the past 3-4 years.

Shame on you

nunusguy
01-10-2008, 01:21 PM
So tell me, who do you draft with those picks to replace him? There is minimal improvement considering you lose one of the best in football, for 2 picks that COULD be good. They could also stink. Yeah, pull the trigger on the gun you point at Parcells for even suggesting anything so rediculous. If we got their 1st,2nd, and 3rd for the next 2 years, maybe.

I dont lknow how any body can see a way to improve by losing the BEST PLAYER ON YOUR TEAM! And one of a few guys on our team that could start for anybody in the NFL. Who do we draft to replace him? Dre Davis and Walter are ok, but come on.
Though AJ is still relatively young, he will be 27 to start next years season,
his 6th, and is now into atleast the middle years of his career for most NFL WRs, though some do seem to go on indefininitely like the 34 year old TO.
But the first overall & the 32nd overall is a tremendous combined value that
the astute Rick Smith could parlay into even more high picks.
Of course this is all idle BS as we begin to try to get thru the long offseason, but what the heck anyway I'll play along. And like I said, I'm an AJ fan but we are just talking business here, sorta.

ObsiWan
01-10-2008, 02:08 PM
So you guys are seriously considering giving up a "bird in the hand" for "two maybes in the bush"...?

ATX
01-10-2008, 02:16 PM
I wouldn't give up a known(AJ) for the unknown(draft picks). Let's just say we got a couple first rounders for him........maybe we hit on one of them and pick up a player of Andre's importance and skill, but its' all a maybe. Andre is in his prime and the most important player on this team.....would we really want a couple new rookies to come in and replace him? Teams don't win Super Bowsl by trading away their best player.

Ole Miss Texan
01-10-2008, 02:24 PM
This could be tempting but Andre Johnson is here to stay on the Texans:

Andre Johnson for Miami's 2008 1st and 2nd rd picks, and 2009 1st rd pick

Trade Miami's #1 overall to Oakland for their 3rd/4th overall + 2nd rd pick so they can draft Chris Long/Glenn Dorsey?

Trade Oaklands 3rd overall to Balimore for their 8th overall and 2nd rd pick so they can draft Matt Ryan ahead of ATL.

So the Texans are left with 2008 first rounders of #8 and #18, 2008 2nd rounders of #1, 3, 8, and 2009 first rd picks of Miami and Houstons

If we stay put there it could look like this:
2008
#8 ) Kenny Phillips FS Miami
#18) Dan Connor OLB Penn St
#33) Antoine Cason CB Arizona
#35) Jeff Otah LT Pitt
#40) Adarius Bowman WR Ok St.
3rd Rd) Tashard Choice RB Georgia Tech

2009
1st rd pick Miami
1st rd pick Houston

In review: Andre Johnson traded for Kenny Phillips, Dan Connor, Antoine Cason, Jeff Otah, Adarius Bowman and a 1st round pick in 2009.

threetoedpete
01-10-2008, 02:45 PM
If they threw in in their 2009 1st rounder, Jason Allen, Matt Roth, and Ronnie Brown... id consider it... but id probably still have alot of reservations about it.

Agreed. He is our rain maker. The only way you pull the trigger involving A.J. is if you get a Hershal Walker type offer. I.E. They give up the farm and a couple of thier vestal Virgins on top.

http://www.yourdictionary.com/vestal-virgin

eriadoc
01-10-2008, 02:51 PM
I plead to the football gods - please let this thread die.

ObsiWan
01-10-2008, 04:22 PM
I plead to the football gods - please let this thread die.


can't...
look...:eek:

a - way...

:hairpull:

BigBull17
01-10-2008, 05:27 PM
Though AJ is still relatively young, he will be 27 to start next years season,
his 6th, and is now into atleast the middle years of his career for most NFL WRs, though some do seem to go on indefininitely like the 34 year old TO.
But the first overall & the 32nd overall is a tremendous combined value that
the astute Rick Smith could parlay into even more high picks.
Of course this is all idle BS as we begin to try to get thru the long offseason, but what the heck anyway I'll play along. And like I said, I'm an AJ fan but we are just talking business here, sorta.

Yeah, bad business. AJ is one of the few on our roster that make us relevent. With out him, we are picking slightly earlier than 18. If you thought the **** stomr was bad for passing Reggie, can you imaagine the flak for trading one of the best PLAYERS in the game. Not one of the best recievers, but best players. Hands down thw best on our team by far. No amount of picks you could reasonably get could equal his contribution. :gun:

False Start
01-10-2008, 08:34 PM
I just had a crazy dream that Miami offered us their 2008 1st and 2nd round draft picks (#1 & #33 overall) for Andre - would you do it? What is the minimum it would take for you to trade Andre, and what would be a realistic trade value be for Andre?

NO ! :elle:

BSofA04
01-10-2008, 11:34 PM
Hell no I wouldn't trade him. He signed a multi-year extension so that he can basically retire (or at least give us his best years) as a Texan. He even took a pay cut per year for job security with this franchise. I wouldn't consider trading a high character, high talent, high production player.

powerfuldragon
01-11-2008, 03:51 PM
trade aj? more like nightmare.