View Full Version : Overrated/Underrated

04-19-2007, 12:47 PM
as per SI.com (http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2007/writers/stewart_mandel/04/19/overrated.underrated/index.html). Some interesting names on there.

04-19-2007, 12:49 PM
A couple examples:

Underrated: Dan Mozes, West Virginia

The NFL is so rigid when it comes to the sizes it looks for at certain positions, that this 6-2 1/2, 293-pound center is barely considered draftable despite being one of the nation's most respected linemen the past two years. West Virginia ran for more than 300 yards per game last year, and Mozes was right at the center of attack. How many times did we see Steve Slaton or Pat White bursting through huge, gaping holes right in the center of the field? Particularly in a zone-blocking scheme like the Mountaineers', everything starts with the center, and Mozes was one of the nation's best. It's hard to believe he's not worthy of a selection somewhere over the course of seven rounds.

Overrated: Chris Houston, Arkansas

He's this year's definitive workout wonder. Houston was a good, not great cornerback for the Razorbacks last season, excelling in some games (USC, Tennessee), struggling in others (South Carolina, Florida). But he ran a 4.32 at the combine, bench-pressed some ridiculous amount and now suddenly he's the second coming of Lito Sheppard -- or at least a solid first-rounder. Not buying it. Houston certainly talks a big game, but he still casts no shortage of doubt. Perhaps some teams are that desperate for a cornerback (because top prospects Leon Hall and Aaron Ross aren't exactly sure-locks, either).

Errant Hothy
04-19-2007, 12:58 PM
I agree with some like Chris Houston, LaMarr Woodley being overrated; but his underrated list is just moronic to me. Troy Smith isn't underrated he's rated where he should be, Rice is a Steve Spuirrer WR which means if anything he's overated (name teh last Speirrer coach wide out he didn't bust in the NFL), Michael Bush isn't underrated he's a big-time medical risk.

And saying Bowe is overrated yet saying that Jarret in near the same level as CJ is just plain stupid.

04-19-2007, 01:35 PM
Mandel is a hack writer.

I like his comment on why Irons is overrated, but earlier said to mention Quinn in the same breath as J Russel is hard for him to believe.

Irons' reputation was basically built during one particularly impressive six-game stretch toward the end of his junior season.

Isn't that exactly what Russel did. Russel before last year was not even on peoples radar as far as a first round pick. He is talking out of his butt with sports info.