PDA

View Full Version : Which QB?


amazingandre
02-21-2007, 12:59 PM
Pick which one of the two you would want on your all-star team......

Trap_Star
02-21-2007, 01:02 PM
All-star game/team: Manning
Regular season: Manning
Playoffs: Brady
Superbowl: Brady

real
02-21-2007, 01:54 PM
Can't go wrong with either. These two are the best QB's in the leauge, and who you vote for has to do with A) favoritism B) What have you done for me lately C) I don't like the other guy

I chose brady because of choice A.

Stros5Texans80
02-21-2007, 03:49 PM
Brady has shown me more in the playoffs and SB overall mostly because he's been there more. He also doesn't have big talent but still lead them to the AFC Championsihp game while beating the first seeded team.

As for Manning. He's got tremendous talent on his offense so that helps him big. I think if Brady had his kind of personel, he would have won 1-2 more SB's.

kiwitexansfan
02-21-2007, 04:31 PM
Brady.... something about his character/leadership vibe that Manning doesn't seem to have.

I still remember last year Manning throwing his OL under the bus.

J-Storm
02-22-2007, 03:28 AM
I have to take Brady. Like said above, he does DAMN well considering he doesnt have the arsenal of quality on Offense as Manning does and yet he is still rather clutch...

kastofsna
02-22-2007, 08:44 AM
Brady.... something about his character/leadership vibe that Manning doesn't seem to have.

I still remember last year Manning throwing his OL under the bus.
i remember brady doing the same thing this year. blah blah blah who cares. i want more QB's to call out their teammates that don't do their job. especially since he also took plenty of responsibility.

amazingandre
02-22-2007, 07:00 PM
It's so funny......on other posts people say they want wins which lead ultimately to a super bowl.....but whne it comes down to a qb that has NO offensive weapons and has 3 sp titles....then why even consider manning??????he won one sb......and brady 3....logic says take the winner every time.......just like all the vy groupies who say we f'd up by passing on a proven winner.......wth???????

GoPats
02-27-2007, 10:36 AM
All-star game/team: Manning
Regular season: Manning
Playoffs: Brady
Superbowl: Brady

All homerism aside, I think this is a good assessment. Despite the fact that Manning finally won a SB, Brady is still the NFL's current leader in playoff wins, percentage, etc. But when it comes to eye-popping numbers, Manning is the guy.

I always wonder what would happen if the Pats had just one top-echelon receiver. Someone better than Deion Branch... a Marvin Harrison or Chad Johnson type.

TwinSisters
02-27-2007, 10:58 AM
I always wonder what would happen if the Pats had just one top-echelon receiver. Someone better than Deion Branch... a Marvin Harrison or Chad Johnson type.

Their defense would fall apart. ( because a top notch WR costs 8-10 million a year )

GoPats
02-27-2007, 01:21 PM
Their defense would fall apart. ( because a top notch WR costs 8-10 million a year )

Good point.

bavanlan
02-27-2007, 02:31 PM
As for Manning. He's got tremendous talent on his offense so that helps him big. I think if Brady had his kind of personel, he would have won 1-2 more SB's.

I think if Manning had Belichick and that defense, Manning would have won more as well.

yourfavoritetexan42
02-27-2007, 02:37 PM
Manning is the heart beat for the colts.

Tom Brady isn't the heart beat of the Patriots.

Colts offense has always been incredible year in and year out.

Holds record for most touchdowns in a season.

Always a top 3 QB rating

Is a coach on the field.


Peyton Manning, no question. Tom Brady is on a good team. Peyton Manning is on a good team, because of him.

crunk-juice
02-28-2007, 06:25 PM
brady is NOTHING compared to manning. i cant believe these comparisons are even in existence. whos better, andrew walters or joe montana?

bATXle red
02-28-2007, 08:55 PM
brady over manning... manning is a crybaby... :crying:

BleedTheBurntOrange
02-28-2007, 09:09 PM
Amazing how many people are for Manning after just 1 Super Bowl.

If Brady had what Manning did on offense Brady would of won this year and the year before. Brady no question he's the best quarterback of this generation and could end up being the best of all time.

He just wins. Give Manning Brady's offense and he would win none. zero. zilch. nada.

Trap_Star
02-28-2007, 11:23 PM
Manning is the heart beat for the colts.

Tom Brady isn't the heart beat of the Patriots.

Colts offense has always been incredible year in and year out.

Holds record for most touchdowns in a season.

Always a top 3 QB rating

Is a coach on the field.


Peyton Manning, no question. Tom Brady is on a good team. Peyton Manning is on a good team, because of him.

LOL, you cannot be serious. So without Brady the Pats still would of won all those superbowls, and they still would of made it to the AFC championship game this year?...

GoPats
03-01-2007, 09:35 AM
Manning is the heart beat for the colts.

Tom Brady isn't the heart beat of the Patriots.
Colts offense has always been incredible year in and year out.

Peyton Manning, no question. Tom Brady is on a good team. Peyton Manning is on a good team, because of him.

Just to back up what Trap_Star said...

Yeah, he is. There's a common misconception out there among the misinformed that Brady stepped on to an all-time-great team and just didn't screw it up. The Patriots were 5-11 the year before he became the starter, and 0-2 when he took over when Mo Lewis hit Drew Bledsoe into the ICU. The Patriots had a solid (but aging) defenese, but they weren't the juggernaut that they became later, in '03 and '04 (under Brady).

Also...

As of this year's AFC Championship Game against Indy, there were only 10 players on the roster who were on the Patriots' first SB team against the Rams. 10 players. Among the core players, Brady is THE most important, followed closely by Seymour.

You may not like Brady - that's fine. No problem there. But to say he's not the heart of the Pats is just plain wrong. I've been a huge Pats fan since I was a kid in the 70s, watching Plunkett and Hannah and Stanley Morgan, etc, and I follow the team as closely as a fan can.

Without Tom Brady, there would be no Lombardi trophies in New England. Anyone who knows this team would tell you the same exact thing.

GoPats
03-01-2007, 09:37 AM
I think if Manning had Belichick and that defense, Manning would have won more as well.

So are you saying Tony Dungy doesn't know what he's doing? :winky:

(I keed, I keed...)

Showtime100
03-01-2007, 10:29 AM
If I was coaching an AS game, and really wanted to win above all else, I'd pick Brady. I'm guessing here, but I think Brady would adjust to an offense that he's not used to better and adjust to recievers he's not used to better.