PDA

View Full Version : 43 or 34 first rd picks


PHILLYTEXANFAN
12-02-2013, 07:52 PM
Khalil Mack 34 OLB - Buffalo


Or


Jadevon Clowney 43 DE S. Carolina

stingray
12-02-2013, 07:56 PM
Khalil Mack 34 OLB - Buffalo


Or


Jadevon Clowney 43 DE S. Carolina

I would rather have Anthony Barr.

TexansSeminole
12-02-2013, 08:03 PM
I would rather have Anthony Barr.

Yeah, I've watched Barr a lot since the beginning of THIS season and like him a lot for 3-4 OLB. Didn't get a chance to watch him last year.

stingray
12-02-2013, 08:06 PM
The kid is an athlete and has a motor that runs full speed unlike Clowney. Barr changed from rb to a pass rusher and dominated from day one. Over 22 sacks in two seasons.

bah007
12-02-2013, 10:33 PM
Barr 34 OLB

or

Clowney 34 DE

or

Clowney 43 DE

bhsman
12-02-2013, 11:08 PM
Is Clowney big enough to play DE, though? He certainly has the height but would need to add about 15 points to match Watt in weight. Grabbing Clowney as a DE would certainly make resigning Smith less likely unless he took a sweetheart deal; he'd be great in the rotation and for teaching Clowney.

bah007
12-02-2013, 11:13 PM
Depends on the scheme. He'd be just fine in a one gap, not in a two.

Corrosion
12-02-2013, 11:17 PM
34 - Bridgewater
43 - Bridgewater
46 - Bridgewater
308 - Bridgewater


We aint winning jack sh!t with the caliber of QB play we've had to endure this season ... Keenum aint the guy.

PapaL
12-03-2013, 12:48 PM
34 - Bridgewater
43 - Bridgewater
46 - Bridgewater
308 - Bridgewater


We aint winning jack sh!t with the caliber of QB play we've had to endure this season ... Keenum aint the guy.

Can't win every shootout. Someone is going to have to play D eventually.

I like both Bridgewater and Clowney. I can see a scenario where we take Clowney #1 and whatever top QB is left at #33; a Tajh Boyd type. Would that make passing on Bridgewater do-able?

bhsman
12-03-2013, 01:19 PM
34 - Bridgewater
43 - Bridgewater
46 - Bridgewater
308 - Bridgewater


We aint winning jack sh!t with the caliber of QB play we've had to endure this season ... Keenum aint the guy.

In fairness, you can't win with 31 points if the other team scores 34.

Corrosion
12-03-2013, 06:02 PM
Can't win every shootout. Someone is going to have to play D eventually.

I like both Bridgewater and Clowney. I can see a scenario where we take Clowney #1 and whatever top QB is left at #33; a Tajh Boyd type. Would that make passing on Bridgewater do-able?

In fairness, you can't win with 31 points if the other team scores 34.

You either have a franchise QB .... or you go get one. Boyd , McCarron , Murray don't have Tom Brady potential Mariota is going back to Oregon for another season. There is no one player in this draft that could change the fortunes of this franchise more than a franchise QB. Its Bridgewater or ..... more of the same , complaining about not having that guy for another decade.


Im tired of the other teams having that guy and we just get to look forward to him carving up our defense ... Its high time the shoe was on the other foot.

powda
12-03-2013, 07:12 PM
You either have a franchise QB .... or you go get one. Boyd , McCarron , Murray don't have Tom Brady potential Mariota is going back to Oregon for another season. There is no one player in this draft that could change the fortunes of this franchise more than a franchise QB. Its Bridgewater or ..... more of the same , complaining about not having that guy for another decade.


Im tired of the other teams having that guy and we just get to look forward to him carving up our defense ... Its high time the shoe was on the other foot.

I agree with you about the importance of a qb...but people throw about names like Peyton and Brady fairly regularly in these conversations. Those guys are 2 of the all time best and they only come about rarely. Is bridgwater that guy? I dunno and don't claim to...infact most of you guys have probably seen a helleva lot more then I have. I do agree a great qb can carve up defenses and I do agree a good qb can take a mediocre team to the playoffs...

But

I also know turnovers are one of the biggest factors in wins/losses. Seems to me a pass rush is the easiest way to create them. For all of Peytons success lets remember he had freeney and mathis tee'ing off on the opposite side. That surely didn't hurt peytons constant trips into the post season.

I say all that to get to my real point: don't overrate a qb because we need one. Dont overrate a qb because having a great one makes us a much better team. If bridge and or whoever else isn't that guy, don't make him that guy. Trust your scouting. Dont pass on the next L.T. or Reggie White for Akili Smith.

Right now I'm on board with clowney. Him and watt going apeshyt on opposing qb's sounds awesome. Both pass rushers who can stop the run as well...just wow.

PapaL
12-04-2013, 08:23 AM
You either have a franchise QB .... or you go get one. Boyd , McCarron , Murray don't have Tom Brady potential Mariota is going back to Oregon for another season. There is no one player in this draft that could change the fortunes of this franchise more than a franchise QB. Its Bridgewater or ..... more of the same , complaining about not having that guy for another decade.


Im tired of the other teams having that guy and we just get to look forward to him carving up our defense ... Its high time the shoe was on the other foot.

Tom Brady didn't have Tom Brady potential when he was drafted. He neither had Franchise QB nor HoF written all over him when he was drafted in the 6th. Drafting a QB #1 is not a guarantee that he'll be top flight.

Honestly I'm fine with either Bridgewater or Clowney, the 2 best players on offense and defense going into the draft.

Marshall
12-04-2013, 08:47 AM
Tom Brady didn't have Tom Brady potential when he was drafted. He neither had Franchise QB or HoF written all over him when he was drafted in the 6th. Drafting a QB #1 is not a guarantee that he'll be top flight.

Honestly I'm fine with either Bridgewater or Clowney, the 2 best players on offense and defense going into the draft.

I'm not impressed with either Bridgewater or Clowney. Neither plays up to good competition, but rather dominates lesser competition. This does not bode well for an NFL player.

My choices are Jake Matthews or Barr. If a top 5 team really wants Bridgewater, then strike a deal to move down for additional draft picks.

The1ApplePie
12-04-2013, 09:20 AM
I'm not impressed with either Bridgewater or Clowney. Neither plays up to good competition, but rather dominates lesser competition. This does not bode well for an NFL player.

My choices are Jake Matthews or Barr. If a top 5 team really wants Bridgewater, then strike a deal to move down for additional draft picks.

The same was said about Mario Williams when he was coming out (the video of him getting his ass handed to him by D'Brick Ferguson would usually follow). Many times the freakish athletes get half-assed coaching, then explode in the NFL when they are properly taught.

Again, the Texans have no QB or pass rush outside JJ Watt. Taking a luxury pick like Matthews doesn't seem to be an option

WolverineFan
12-04-2013, 12:29 PM
I'm not impressed with either Bridgewater or Clowney. Neither plays up to good competition, but rather dominates lesser competition. This does not bode well for an NFL player.

That is a complete generalization, at least as far as Bridgewater is concerned. His best games are against the best teams on the schedule. If anything it's the opposite that's true. He tends to not show up against the lesser competition and plays better against top competition.

VTexan
12-04-2013, 01:04 PM
give me the player that shows up against the big teams over the player that dominates the smaller teams and disappears when it matters. hasn't that been the problem of our teams of the last few seasons?

every
day
of
the
week