PDA

View Full Version : Schaub vs Romo vs Big ben


Norg
07-20-2013, 11:09 PM
who is the better QB ... BUT take out the team awards and big ben rings

just player vs player

they were discussing this on the radio

PapaL
07-20-2013, 11:31 PM
Define better.

Norg
07-21-2013, 12:23 AM
Define better.

pocket passer
Arm strength
Mobility
Pocket awareness
Decesion Making
Reading Def
Footwork
Toughness
Leadership
vision


etc etc etc comparing those things

Goatcheese
07-21-2013, 01:16 AM
Overall:

Rapistburger
Schaub
Romo

pocket passer
Schaub
Romo
Rapistburger

Arm strength
Rapistburger
Schaub = Romo

Mobility
Rapistburger
Romo
Schaub

Pocket awareness
Rapistburger
Romo
Schaub

Decision Making
Schaub
Rapistburger
A drunk teenage girl
Romo

Reading Def
Schaub
Romo
Rapistburger

Toughness

Toughness or durability? Schaub and Rapistburger have both tried to play through serious injuries (broken bones, torn ligaments, etc.). That's man mode right there. I don't know if Romo has.

vision

Inside the pocket
Romo
Schaub
Rapistburger

Outside the pocket
Rapistburger
Romo
Schaub

The Pencil Neck
07-21-2013, 03:37 AM
Toughness

Toughness or durability? Schaub and Rapistburger have both tried to play through serious injuries (broken bones, torn ligaments, etc.). That's man mode right there. I don't know if Romo has.



Romo has played through broken ribs and a collapsed lung. He's tough. They're all tough guys.

thunderkyss
07-21-2013, 09:24 AM
I think it depends on the team you put around them. If you've got a pretty good team, defense, running game, WR/TEs.... Matt Schaub, hands down.

but if your WRs can't get open, or you've got nothing but burners I'd say Roethlisburger.

If it's some combination in between, I'd probably go with Romo.

I think Ben can do more with less, then Romo to a lesser extent. But if you got a good team, I think Schaub can make the most of it, keep them on schedule, make them pay if they aren't honest, score efficiently.

EllisUnit
07-21-2013, 10:58 AM
Under pressure

Big Ben
Schaub
Romom

We have seen Romo just lose it all everytime he plays a big time game, and he has played more than Schaub. And then Schaub always under performs in the spotlight of a pressured game, he nearly gave away the wild card game to the Bengals last season with that late Pick 6, then again against greenbay, and the pats. He did do very well in mile high against peyton. but overall has not been good in pressured games, Big ben has a few rings so not really a question, and IMO big games are the only ones that matter.

Playoffs
07-21-2013, 12:36 PM
I've seen Big Ben put teams on his back and carry them to victories... sometimes with suspect run games and iffy offensive lines.

Haven't seen that from the other two.

infantrycak
07-21-2013, 12:43 PM
I've seen Big Ben put teams on his back and carry them to victories... sometimes with suspect run games and iffy offensive lines.

Haven't seen that from the other two.

Really? - when?

thunderkyss
07-21-2013, 02:01 PM
I've seen Big Ben put teams on his back and carry them to victories... sometimes with suspect run games and iffy offensive lines.

Haven't seen that from the other two.


I remember a few years back the word was the Steelers could return to their winning ways if they could run the ball. "They" said if you're asking Ben Roethlisberger to throw the ball 40+ times a game, your game plan is flawed.


Romo would be hell if he had a run game.

Nawzer
07-21-2013, 03:14 PM
Big Ben. No doubt.

thunderkyss
07-21-2013, 05:10 PM
Stats don't compare to hardware

Rothlisberger

everyone else doesn't matter

Who's better, Hines Ward or Andre Johnson?

thunderkyss
07-21-2013, 05:31 PM
Ward 2 super bowl rings

You're funny.

thunderkyss
07-21-2013, 06:04 PM
Let me put it another way if I may

if you and were standing in a crowded room, and you had $20 dollars in your hand and
I had a million dollars in mine..who would the crowd gravitate towards more???

That won't make you a better janitor than me. Let me put it to you this way, David Carr has a Super Bowl ring. Tony Romo does not.

Who is the better QB?

Should Jerrah bring Carr in to lead the Cowboys since David has the hardware & Romo does not?

paycheck71
07-21-2013, 06:28 PM
Ward 2 super bowl rings

This is such an oversimplification and not at all how the world works. Robert Horry has 6 rings, and Charles Barkley has none. One of them is a hall of famer, and the other is not. You can find countless other examples across multiple sports.

NCTexan
07-21-2013, 06:41 PM
What is so funny bout what I said?

the fact is stats don't compare to hardware!!

I'll let the Lions know they need to waive Megatron and get Ward out of retirement ASAP!

EllisUnit
07-21-2013, 08:26 PM
What is so funny bout what I said?

the fact is stats don't compare to hardware!! I know BSPN and the mindless mediots
have been bashing peoples brains in, convincing them that this is the little league and
everyone is a winner at the years end

But it just ain't true!!

sports has room for 1 team comprised of 53 individual men (this case) who began on
a journey to take home a coveted prize that just isn't easy to grab a hold of any
more

Ward worked his ass off along with his teammates to achieve the impossible and
did it. the others mentioned just don't belong in the same ball park simple as that

so the 5th string WR who sat on the bench and got a SB ring is better than AJ to is what ur saying ? Thats a joke, we all know Barry Sanders was one of the best RBs to ever play the game and he has 0 rings. That dont make all the scrub RBs with rings better than him.

b0ng
07-22-2013, 03:55 PM
Let me put it another way if I may

if you and were standing in a crowded room, and you had $20 dollars in your hand and
I had a million dollars in mine..who would the crowd gravitate towards more???

Lets ask a different question then:

Trent Dilfer or Dan Marino?

thunderkyss
07-22-2013, 07:11 PM
The answer is all ways going to be the same, the 1 with the ring is better than the 1
w/o it, players aren't playing for stats and meaningless attributes they want gold just
like any one who plays sports

the main goal is to be #1 the way you become #1 is by winning a world championship
simple as that

So you're trading Tony Romo for David Carr? It's that kind of thinking that's got Jerrah lost in the wilderness for the last decade.

Chicken & egg, horse & cart, & all that sort of thing.

StarStruck
07-22-2013, 07:26 PM
Taken from my Facebook page.

Monday Night Football's status.

6 more Mondays to go until MNF kicks off!

SHARE IF YOU CAN'T WAIT!!!

:doot:

Norg
07-23-2013, 01:00 AM
yeah Andre has zero and ward has some rings but think back in 03-08 if Andre was playing for the steelers how much better u think they would of been

sometimes well all the times its about the TEAM and the right team that comes together to win the Rings in every team tho u got Just straight up play makers or "players" OR GAMERS

Mr teX
07-23-2013, 05:07 PM
:kubepalm:

The season can't get here fast enough...